Sunday, August 18, 2013

Lafitte's Blacksmith Shop - Oldest Bar?

            One of the many things I love about this city is the ease with which one can travel through time.  New Orleans doesn’t throw anything away and so documents, newspapers, journals, letters, insurance maps, city directories, etc., all end up in archival collections which are open to the public.  Anyone can go and suddenly you’re in the 1840’s, physically holding a bail bond signed by Marie Laveau or staring at Rose Nicaud’s permit to operate a coffee stand at stall #16 in the French Market.  When I come across a claim or a story or a legend I want it to be true; I want Adelina Patti to have saved the French Opera House (she did); I want Antoine Peychaud to have invented the cocktail (he didn’t); I want the Pharmacie Français to be the first pharmacy building in the United States (it is) and I want everything they say about Lafitte’s Blacksmith Shop to be true - but like so much else...it just....isn’t.

            The owners of Lafitte’s Blacksmith Shop have only been making the claim to be The Oldest Bar In The U.S.A. since Katrina.  Prior to that, their claim was a little different.  When I began working for Magic Tours in 2005 their ghost tour was leaving from The Blacksmith Shop.  At that time The Blacksmith Shop was claiming to be “the oldest building in the United States to house a bar.”  After Katrina they began selling t-shirts with the phrase “The oldest bar in the U.S.A.” and every carriage driver in the city backed it up.  I never questioned the “oldest building” claim (didn’t feel I had a reason to) but this new claim struck a chord with me.  I am a volunteer for the New Orleans City Archives since the mid-1990’s and I did a two-year project for them which ended up being one of the most rewarding and enlightening things I’ve ever done.

            There was a cartography firm called Sanborn that made maps and surveys in cities around the country for use in fire insurance.  (Click here for more information on Sanborn Maps.)  Their documentation is very thorough and extremely complete - detailing the buildings, their addresses (and in New Orleans they include the buildings' old and new addresses, which is valuable when one is researching a building prior to the address renumbering in 1895), their construction, who owned them and (most importantly) how they were used.  I processed the Sanborn survey of 1897 for the City Archives; in fact, they said I could keep the photocopies of the Sanborn file they sent me and they are still in my library and I still refer to them frequently.  According to that directory, the building that is now Lafitte’s Blacksmith was owned by a C. Mongo and served as a combination oyster shop and cobbler.  In rooting around in other records I found that the property had a dependancy to the side where the courtyard is which was demolished around 1910 and that the oyster shop was in the outbuilding while the building which still stands on the corner served as the cobbler shop.  (Attached is a photo taken circa 1895 which shows the outbuilding at the side - notice both the outbuilding and the main building each feature vitrines [display windows] - it's a shame that the sign on the main building is unreadable.)

            So in 2006 when Lafitte's Blacksmith Shop's bar-back, Darryl, began wearing a t-shirt with the claim to the oldest bar in the United States, I questioned it and he got a little defensive and simply said that the claim was true.  I spoke to the manager and told him about the Sanborn maps and questioned how they could claim to be the oldest bar in the country since 1772 when they also claim to have been a blacksmith shop in the Lafitte era and that I have records that show it was a cobbler shop in 1897.  He got so defensive that he banned me from the bar.  (Luckily I was in good with the bartenders and they didn’t enforce it, since he wasn’t there at night anyway.  I did, however, decide against pressing the issue.)  In fact, their own website claims that the Lafitte Brothers used the building between 1772  and 1791.  An interesting claim considering Pierre Laffite (the Laffite boys spelled their name Laffite) didn’t even come to Louisiana until 1803 (he was a refugee from San Domingue) and Jean followed after him later.  Plus - it was a bar AND a blacksmith shop at the same time???

            As for when the building became a bar - the first record of a barroom permit for that address is in 1933 when Mary Collins, Thomas Caplinger and Harold Bartell opened a restaurant there called “Café Lafitte.”  And yes, it was an actual restaurant, not just a saloon.  In his 1945 dining guide Scoop Kennedy describes the restaurant as serving steaks, fried oysters, liver and onions and roast beef.  Of course, Café Lafitte was later “exiled” and became the gay bar.  Business licenses for that location prior to 1933 range from groceries to shoemakers to dentists.  The 1842 city directory lists two dentists, GUIROUD and VALENCOURT, practicing in that building.  Dentists!  Who knew?

            So what, then, is the oldest bar in the United States?  The White Horse Tavern in Newport, R.I. can trace their liquor licenses to 1702, although not continuously.  From 1895 to 1957 it served as a boarding house.  As for the oldest bar in New Orleans, The Old Absinthe House has been serving liquor at least since the 1880’s and is probably the oldest continuing operating bar in the city.  In fact, they operated an annex at the corner of St. Ann and Chartres in a building that once stood where the current Muriel’s building was built later.

Lafitte's Blacksmith Shop, circa 1895
Note the small building to the left of the main building.

Branch of the Absinthe House, corner St. Ann & Chartres, circa 1880
Demolished circa 1900 to build the current Muriel's Restaurant.

15 comments:

  1. Does anybody know where Pierre and Jean actually resided? I read that Pierre had a blacksmith shop and owed, what is not called a warehouse, in 1805 in New Orleans that they used for all the goods they smuggled. I also heard that they had a residence on an island in Baratarria. If the so called, Laffite's Blacksmith Shop, was not actually owned or used by the Laffite brothers, is there any records of what was actually owned and operated by them and were these places on the city of New Orleans or in outer lying areas?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Typos are *owned instead of owed and *what is now instead of what is not.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'am glad to read the whole content of this blog and am very excited.Thank you.

    แคมฟรอก

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi, great blog. You described "staring at Rose Nicaud’s permit to operate a coffee stand at stall #16 in the French Market." Can you tell me the year the permit was issued? Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  5. Do you have a source for the barroom permit in 1933? The HNOC has a quote from a guidebook in 1937 describing the location as a plumbers shop, and the only source I find for the 1933 permit is Atlas Obscura, which lists you as the source.

    ""...This so-called "Lafitte Smithy", if you are interested in facts, was probably never put to such a use, in spite of the words on the iron plaque now decorating its Bourbon Street wall. It is, however, a very ancient structure for our careful search through musty notarial acts takes us back to the fifteenth day of December, 1772, when Don Andres Almonester y Roxas, then a lowly escribano público, set down the terms of a realty transfer. The second notary to record a sale of this property was Jean Garic, who scribbled a hard-to-read document in 1773. In 1791 this little house was included when listing the succession of Bartholome Robert and the site and building were sold to the Widow Simon Duroché, who had been Marguerite Robert. Senor Duroché, it appears, had an alias, which the careful notary set down as "Castillion." It was not until September 24, 1833, that the Widow Duroché sold the place to the Widow Christian Miltenberger. From owner to owner the little house was transferred until it reached its present status - a plumber's shop."


    — Source: Old New Orleans: A History of the Vieux Carré Author: Stanley Clisby Arthur Date: Friday, January 1st 1937"

    ReplyDelete
  6. Buying YouTube subscribers instantly uplifts a channel's reputation, giving the impression of a thriving community and increased authority. This strategy accelerates a channel's visibility, encouraging more natural engagement from prospective viewers attracted by the lively subscriber base. Instant subscribers can trigger a ripple effect, where organic viewer interest escalates, leading to potentially higher watch times and engagement rates. Channels benefit from improved algorithmic recognition, elevating their chances of being featured in YouTube's coveted recommendation sections. This approach can rapidly validate new channels, propelling them into the spotlight and helping them stand out amidst the digital crowd. It's a means of fast-tracking the growth curve, setting the stage for broader recognition, and fostering a stronger, more commanding online presence.
    https://www.buyyoutubesubscribers.in/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Lasik surgery in Delhi is a testament to the leaps of progress in the field of ophthalmology, offering a promising avenue for those afflicted with vision impairments to reclaim their sight. This procedure, characterized by its precision and minimal invasiveness, utilizes advanced laser technology to accurately reshape the cornea, correcting refractive errors such as myopia, hyperopia, and astigmatism. Renowned for its quick recovery period, patients can often marvel at the immediate enhancement in their vision, with most resuming their normal activities within days. The capital city's highly skilled ophthalmologists, backed by cutting-edge facilities, dedicate themselves to providing personalized and compassionate care, ensuring optimal results. With a focus on safety, efficacy, and patient satisfaction, Lasik surgery in Delhi stands as a beacon of medical excellence, transforming lives by affording individuals the gift of clear vision.
    https://www.visualaidscentre.com/lasik-eye-surgery/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Buying YouTube subscribers in India has carved out a niche as a somewhat controversial yet increasingly popular avenue for content creators desiring quick visibility and channel growth. This method seeks to inflate a channel's subscriber count artificially, thereby enhancing its social proof and perceived value among potential viewers. Leveraging human psychology, a larger subscriber base often translates to higher credibility and organic viewer traction. However, this strategy walks a fine line with YouTube’s stringent policies against artificial engagement, posing a significant risk to a channel's integrity and long-term success. Therefore, engagement through this method must be meticulously planned, with a strong focus on partnering with providers that offer real, active subscribers. Despite its allure for rapid growth, the sustainability and authenticity of a channel hinge on the continuous delivery of compelling, high-quality content that resonates with the target audience.
    https://sites.google.com/view/buyytsubscribers/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Cheap website hosting in India transcends the balance between affordability and efficiency, offering a golden opportunity for startups, small businesses, and individuals to secure a spot on the digital landscape. It provides an array of scalable packages that cater to different needs, from simple blogs to comprehensive e-commerce platforms, ensuring no one is left behind. These hosting services come packed with essential features like unlimited bandwidth, sufficient storage, and robust security measures to protect against cyber threats. They are designed with user-friendliness in mind, featuring intuitive control panels for easy website management and one-click installations for popular CMS platforms. With servers located within India, they guarantee faster website loading times for local visitors, greatly improving the overall user experience. Additionally, the emphasis on reliable uptime and readily available customer support ensures that any issues are swiftly addressed, keeping websites smoothly operational. This combination of features makes cheap website hosting in India an unrivaled choice for those looking to establish a strong online presence without breaking the bank.
    https://onohosting.com/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Buying YouTube views in India has become a strategic step for content creators and businesses aiming to enhance their visibility on one of the world's largest video-sharing platforms. This service provides an immediate boost to video view counts, propelling content toward higher rankings and increased visibility. By leveraging high-quality and region-specific views, creators can significantly improve their chances of being discovered by a wider, potentially more engaged audience. This, in turn, can lead to higher organic growth, more subscribers, and increased ad revenue over time. Furthermore, having a high number of views from the outset can help establish credibility and attract more viewers, creating a positive feedback loop that benefits content creators. Importantly, opting for reputable service providers ensures that the views come from real users, complying with YouTube's policies and safeguarding the channel's reputation.
    https://www.buyyoutubeviewsindia.in/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Buying YouTube subscribers in India is a strategy that some content creators use to artificially inflate their subscriber counts, aiming to enhance their channel's appearance of popularity and credibility. This technique is seen as a way to quickly make a channel more appealing to potential organic subscribers, with the hope that a higher subscriber count will lead to increased visibility and growth. However, the engagement level of these purchased subscribers is often minimal, as they are typically not genuinely interested in the channel's content. While providers of such services tout rapid increases in subscriber numbers, this approach risks violating YouTube's terms of service, which could lead to sanctions against the channel, including suspension. Despite its potential for quick gains, this practice is controversial and may not contribute to long-term channel success, suggesting that organic growth strategies are more beneficial and sustainable for content creators in India.
    https://buyyoutubesubscribersindia.weebly.com/

    ReplyDelete
  12. In the burgeoning digital market of India, the practice of buying Google reviews presents a tempting shortcut for businesses seeking quick visibility and reputation enhancement. Such reviews are often purchased to project an artificially positive image, aiming to lure more customers by showcasing high ratings and favorable feedback. Despite its perceived immediate benefits, this strategy harbors significant risks, including the potential for Google's algorithmic penalties, review removals, or even a complete ban from the platform. Authentic customer feedback remains the gold standard, integral to maintaining credibility and fostering trust among the consumer base. Ethical acquisition of reviews, focusing on delivering quality service and products, is paramount for sustainable success and building a reliable online presence in India's competitive digital landscape.
    https://www.seoexpertindelhi.in/buy-google-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  13. Singapore is actively seeking Indian nurses to join its innovative and world-renowned healthcare system. Nurses have the opportunity to specialize in critical fields such as ICU, Pediatrics, and Oncology. The country offers a competitive salary, extensive benefits, and a focus on continuous professional development within its state-of-the-art medical facilities. Working in Singapore means becoming part of a diverse and technologically advanced medical community, aimed at providing exceptional patient care. It's a chance to grow both professionally and personally while being immersed in a multicultural environment that respects and values your cultural heritage. Indian nurses in Singapore are integral to a healthcare vision that’s globally respected, offering a unique blend of professional opportunity and personal enrichment.
    https://dynamichealthstaff.com/nursing-jobs-in-singapore-for-indian-nurses

    ReplyDelete
  14. Buy Google Reviews Bulk India stands as a transformative service specifically designed for businesses aiming to amplify their online presence effectively and affordably. Providing bulk packages of authentic, high-quality Google reviews, this service targets to simulate genuine customer feedback, thereby elevating a company's reputation and visibility on the internet. Tailored for the Indian market, the reviews boost relevance and engagement with local consumers, making every review an asset for enhancing digital credibility. Bulk purchases allow for significant improvement in a business's online stature at a competitive price point, making it an optimal strategy for growth-oriented companies. Each review is meticulously prepared to ensure authenticity and trust, cementing a business's position in a crowded online marketplace.
    https://www.sandeepmehta.co.in/blog/how-to-promote-youtube-video-in-2021-2/

    ReplyDelete
  15. Looking to boost your music career? Gain an edge with our affordable Spotify follower packages. Our services offer real, engaged followers that will amplify your presence on the platform. Skip the hassle of waiting for organic growth and dive straight into success. With our cheap rates, you can invest in your music without breaking the bank. Build credibility, increase visibility, and reach a wider audience effortlessly. Don't miss out on this opportunity to skyrocket your Spotify presence. Join countless satisfied musicians who have benefitted from our reliable follower service. Invest in your artistry today and watch your fan base flourish. Explore our budget-friendly packages now!
    https://www.spotifyfame.com/

    ReplyDelete